Managing Tenant Default and Lease Rollover Risk in NYC Commercial Real Estate
By The North Star Universal, LLC
At The North Star Universal, LLC, we’ve been closely watching a critical trend in the New York City commercial real-estate landscape: rising tenant default and lease rollover risk. When leases expire and tenants hesitate to renew, especially in uncertain markets, it becomes a fault line in commercial property risk mitigation. It’s our job to help owners and investors stay ahead of that shift.
Why lease rollover risk demands fresh focus
Recent data show that leasing activity in Manhattan is on the rise—availability recently dropped to 16.4 %, the lowest in over four years. (Avison Young) While that might look like good news, it actually signals a double-edged sword. A stronger leasing market often raises tenants’ bargaining power and renewal demands. Owners must manage not just vacancy but the financial impact of weaker lease terms, renewal incentives, and potential defaults during transition periods.
At The North Star Universal, LLC, we view lease rollover risk as more than just “does the tenant renew.” We treat it as an operational risk that influences NOI, affects DSCR, and can upset the exit strategy or property valuation.
A three-pronged case study approach
Case 1: Midtown office with looming rollover
A 500,000 sq ft Class A office building in Midtown faced 35 % of its leases expiring in the next 18 months. The owner assumed renewals would mirror past behavior. At The North Star Universal, LLC we recalculated: if only 60 % of expiring tenants renewed, and the other 40 % left with half the turnover gap filled in the first six months, NOI would drop by $3.2 million next year, dropping DSCR from 1.30× to 1.10×. That shortfall triggered lender alarm. We recommended a pre-emptive tenant-retention campaign plus a lease-rollover contingency fund.
Case 2: Brooklyn industrial park rollover-risk mitigation
An industrial park in Brooklyn had short-term leases coming due—and the owner worried about a tenant exiting to lower-cost New Jersey space. With guidance from The North Star Universal, LLC we applied a strategy: identify tenants with early-option exit rights, renegotiate earlier, and stage CapEx to improve facility attractiveness prior to renewal. As a result, the owner secured renewals on two major tenants six months early, locking in higher rents and reducing vacancy exposure.
Case 3: Global investor in a multi-market retail portfolio
A global investment firm held a retail portfolio across NYC and London. They faced rollover risk at the same time as rising interest rates threatened refinancing. The North Star Universal, LLC advised them to match lease-expiration schedules to financing maturities: aligning risk events so that large rollover exposures did not coincide with hefty debt repayments. This alignment improved cash-flow stability and optimized capital allocation across the investment property strategy.
Key tactics for managing tenant default and lease rollover risk
1. Map upcoming expirations and identify risk zones
Begin by charting lease expirations over the next 24 months by square footage, tenant industry, rent level, and sub-market. At The North Star Universal, LLC we look for clusters where rollover risk is highest—large tenants in volatile industries, upward‐only leases coming due during economic softening, or properties refinanced with tight DSCR.
2. Stress test scenario: what if renewals fall short?
Use modelling that factors in a drop in renewal rate, increased downtime, free rent allowances, or tenant improvements (TI) incentives. Suppose an office property has 40 % of leases rolling this year. If only 50 % renew and downtime averages 4 months, how much does NOI fall, and what happens to DSCR and property valuation? At The North Star Universal, LLC we incorporate these variables into our investment property strategy workshops.
3. Engage tenants proactively and invest strategically
Levers such as early renewal offers, flexible lease terms, improved building amenities, and tenant-friendly CapEx (e.g., hybrid-work zones) can reduce turnover. The North Star Universal, LLC encourages owners to treat lease rollover like a short-cycle operating risk, not just a long-cycle property-management task. Active NYC lease management wins here.
4. Align exit strategy and refinance planning
Lease rollover risks can jeopardize refinancing or sale valuations. If large vacancies hit just as the loan comes due, DSCR may slip below thresholds. Owners should consider staggered maturities, build in vacancy reserves, or capture early renewals as part of their operational risk plan. The North Star Universal, LLC helps clients review how rollover exposure meets debt servicing and exit-strategy timing.
Why this matters now
Even though availability in Manhattan is improving, the leasing market remains highly selective and tenants have more leverage than in previous cycles. Rating agencies flagged that delinquency rates on U.S. office loans hit nearly 11.8 % in recent months. (Reuters) That figure amplifies the risk: a tenant default in a large asset can trigger lender intervention quickly. For owners focused on cash-flow stability and disciplined capital allocation, these numbers underscore the urgency.
Conclusion
At The North Star Universal, LLC we believe that tenant default and lease rollover risk should sit at the heart of any robust commercial property risk mitigation framework. With leases expiring, tenant-demand dynamics shifting, and financing parameters tightening, the time to act is not later—it’s now. By mapping expirations, stress-testing renewal scenarios, engaging tenants early, and aligning leases with financing horizons, investors can preserve NOI, protect DSCR, and maintain value through uncertainty.
We encourage you to review your annual rollover horizon this week. If you identify high-risk clusters, let’s discuss how to convert exposure into opportunity and validate your investment property strategy for the next cycle.
Follow or share this blog for more expert insight.
The North Star Universal, LLC is a risk management and advisory firm. Follow this blog for more insights into the evolving world of NYC realty and beyond @ thenorthstaruniversal.com/WP.
Twitter Facebook Instagram LinkedIn